Scottish Rugby to award two more retrospective caps
Scottish Rugby is to award two more retrospective caps.
The latest recipients are the brothers Simon and Julian Scott, the centre and scrum-half respectively, who represented Edinburgh Rugby and Stewart’s-Melville and also played in other representative teams including Scotland B.
The pair are being added to more than 50 players whom the Scottish Rugby Union Custodian Board decided to honour last month, primarily from Services and Victory internationals during and after the Second World War, and those who played in certain Scotland XV games against national teams, where the opposition awarded caps or where other senior Scotland teams were not playing simultaneously.
Scottish Rugby Union President, Colin Rigby, said: “The response to our retrospective caps’ initiative has been universally positive, especially for the players and families who now proudly hold cap status and with whom we are liaising to conduct cap ceremonies.
“We have also been contacted on behalf of other distinguished players who wore the thistle in non-cap matches at that time, asking us to consider certain such matches and those requests are being considered diligently and respectfully.
“The rationale behind the retrospective capping is to be inclusive, while, at the same time, protecting the integrity of a Scotland cap, so it is important that we look at the circumstances around individual games and remain true to our overall philosophy.”
Pictured above: Julian Scott in action for Edinburgh against Australia at Myreside, 1988.
Both Scott brothers toured Spain and France with Scotland in 1986.
They played for the Scotland XV that met a France XV in Tarbes on Wednesday 7 May that year.
The French team that night contained 14 players who were either capped then or subsequently, including some luminaries of the global game. France XV: Jean-Baptiste Lafond; Patrice Lagisquet, Pierre Chadebech, Serge Blanco, Patrick Esteve; Jean-Patrick Lescarboura, Rodolphe Modin; Philippe Marocco, Christian Rizon, Jean-Pierre Garuet, Francis Haget, Jean Condom, Marc Cecillon, Jean-Charles Orso and Laurent Rodriguez.
The Scots, who had defeated Spain 39-17 in the tour opener and had then lost 19-40 to a Cote Basque XV in their first game in France, achieved a highly creditable 16-all draw in Tarbes.
Scotland’s points (all scored by players who went on to represent the British & Irish Lions) came from tries by John Beattie (senior) and John Jeffrey. Peter Dods added one conversion – keeping in mind that tries were worth four points then – and two penalties.
Later, on that tour, Scotland lost to the French Barbarians 19-32 and beat a Tarn Select 26-7.
Pictured above: Simon Scott in action in the final of the Haig Sevens at Murrayfield, 1983.
The updated retrospective cap list – complete with their unique Scotland cap numbers – now reads:
1141 – Alec Buchanan v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1142 – Morris Dewar v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1143 – ECK Douglas v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1144 – SGA Harper v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1145 – Eric Hunter v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1146 – J Maltman v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1147 – N W Ramsay v England (SI) 21 March 1942
1148 – J B McNeil v England (SI) 11 April 1942
1149 – D A Roberts v England(SI) 11 April 1942
1150 – J M Blair v England (SI) 27 February 1943
1151 – R Cowe v England (SI) 27 February 1943
1152 – Colin McLay v England (SI) 27 February 1943
1153 – W B Biggart v England (SI) 10 April 1943
1154 – Eric Grant v England (SI) 10 April 1943
1155 – Mathew Kennedy v England (SI) 10 April 1943
1156 – A E Murray v England (SI) 26 February 1944
1157 – Jock McClure v England (SI) 18 March 1944
1158 – Henry U’ren v England (SI) 18 March 1944
1159 – Drew Barcroft v England (SI) 24 February 1945
1160 – Jim Henderson v England (SI) 24 February 1945
1161 – R M McKenzie v England (SI) 24 February 1945
1162 – J B Nicholls v England (SI) 24 February 1945
1163 – Jake Thom v England (SI) 24 February 1945
1164 – C Wilhelm v England (SI) 24 February 1945
1165 – E Melling v England (SI) 17 March 1945
1166 – John Anderson v New Zealand Army (VI) 19 January 1946
1167 – J Kirk v New Zealand Army (VI) 19 January 1946
1168 – Kenneth Wilson v England (VI) 16 March 1946
1169 – Ian Murchie v Argentina 13 September 1969
1170 – Arthur Orr v Argentina 13 September 1969
1171 – Bruce Laidlaw v Argentina 27 September 1969
1172 – David Ashton v Japan 25 September 1976
1173 – Jim Carswell v Japan 25 September 1976
1174 – Colin Mair v Japan 18 September 1977
1175 – Rob Moffat v Japan 18 September 1977
1176 – Stuart Johnston v Spain 01 May 1986
1177 – Garry Waite v Spain 01 May 1986
1178 – Julian Scott v France Select 07 May 1986
1179 – Simon Scott v France Select 07 May 1986
1180 – Tim Exeter v France XV 26 September 1987
1181 – Jeremy Macklin v France XV 26 September 1987
1182 – Ian Ramsey v France XV 26 September 1987
1183 – David Butcher v Zimbabwe 21 May 1988
1184 – Ruari Maclean v Zimbabwe 21 May 1988
1185 – Stewart McAslan v Zimbabwe 21 May 1988
1186 – Kevin Rafferty v Zimbabwe 21 May 1988
1187 – Hugh Parker v Zimbabwe 21 May 1988
1188 – Grant Wilson v Japan 28 May 1989
1189 – Mark Moncrieff v USA 18 May 1991
1190 – Ronnie Kirkpatrick v Canada 25 May 1991
1191 – Ally Donaldson v Fiji 29 May 1993
1192 – Steve Ferguson v Fiji 29 May 1993
1193 – Nick Grecian v Fiji 29 May 1993
1194 – Gary Isaac v Fiji 29 May 1993
1195 – Robb Scott v Fiji 29 May 1993
1196 – Craig Redpath v Tonga 05 June 1993
1197 – Willie Anderson v Spain 05 December 1998
SI = Services International
VI = Victory International
One player who was included in our initial list – Flt Officer DD McKenzie (RAF and Merchistonians) who was spelled in that fashion from records of the 1945 Services International against England which Scotland won 18-11 in Leicester, has been removed from the retrospective caps list.
Further research revealed that he was one and the same David Douglas Mackenzie who won six caps for Scotland on the wing in 1947 and 1948 out of Edinburgh University and who was also selected as a member of the British track team at the 1948 London Olympic Games.