MATCH REPORT: Combined Provinces v The Thistles

4 Feb 2023

The Thistles suffered a 45-12 defeat against a clinical Combined Provinces XV outfit in their second match of the Celtic Challenge at Kingspan Stadium in Belfast.

2023 Celtic Challenge, Kingspan Stadium, Belfast, Norther Ireland 4/2/2023 Combined Provinces XV vs The Thistles Thistles' Mairi McDonald makes a pass Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Ben Brady

The Combined Provinces opened the scoring in the early stages of the game, as centre Leah Tarpey powered past multiple defenders to score, with Dannah O’Brien converting the score [7-0].

The home side increased their lead with a second try on 18 minutes, as Claire Bennett crashed over from close range, with O’Brien slotting the conversion through the posts [14-0].

Maeve Óg O’Leary got the home side’s third try on 31 minutes, as Emma Orr’s attempted clearance was charged down and seized by Og O’Leary and the flanker was able to apply downward pressure for the try, with O’Brien adding the extras [21-0].

With pressure building, Combined Provinces sensed another opportunity before the break and were able to captialise when prop Linda Djougang cut through before offloading to Aoife Dalton, the centre fed Ella Roberts, the winger broke a tackle to race over in the corner but O’Brien couldn’t convert from a tight angle [26-0].

The Thistles rallied and were able to retaliate with a minute to go, as Panashe Muzambe spun the ball wide to Francesca McGhie, as the winger sped over from just inside the 22 for an unconverted try to cut the Combined Provinces lead at the interval [26-5].

HALF-TIME: Combined Provinces XV 26-5 The Thistles

The hosts were able to apply pressure at the beginning of the second-half, but The Thistles defence was firm and brought to a halt several attacks.

As the visitors were trying to exit their own 22, some well-worked hands gave Sarah Denholm the opportunity to float the ball out to McGhie who then accelerated down the pitch to score under the posts, with Emma Orr converting [26-12].

The Combined Provinces replied five minutes later, as O’Connor broke from the base of a scrum, Dalton ran a great line to come onto the ball just inside the 22 and went under the posts unopposed with O’Brien converting [33-12].

The hosts continued to dominate proceedings and were able to strengthen their position in the game when winger Roberts scored her second try of the match but O’Connor failed to convert [38-12].

Deirbhile Nic a Bhaird powered her way over for a try on 71 minutes, as the flanker got the ball on the 22 and held over six attempted tackles to reach the line and ground the ball with captain O’Connor converting [45-12].

Combined Provinces XV: Ella Durkan; Clara Barrett, Leah Tarpey, Aoife Dalton, Ella Roberts; Dannah O’Brien Molly Scuffil McCabe; Niamh O’Dowd, Jess Keating, Linda Djougang, Claire Bennett, Fiona Tuite, Deirbhile Nic a Bhaird, Maeve Og O’Leary, Hannah O’Connor

Replacements: Emma Hooban, Mary Healy for Djougang 58 mins Megan Collis, Eimear Corri for Bennett 58nmins, Sophie Barrett for Tuite 66 mins, Katie Whelan for O’Brien 63 mins, Kayla Waldron for Tarpey 66 mins, Maeve Liston for Barrett 66 mins

The Thistles: Roma Fraser; Rachel Philipps, Holly McIntyre, Emma Orr, Francesca McGhie; Sarah Denholm, Mairi McDonald; Panashe Muzambe, Elis Martin, Elliann Clarke, Charlotte Boan, Natasha Logan, Eva Donaldson, Erinn Foley, Freya Walker

Replacements: Nikki Simpson for Walker 52 mins, Poppy Fletcher, Lindsay McDiarmid for Foley 51 mins, Kiera MacDonald, Alex Stewart, Rhea Clarke for McDonald 59 mins, Ceitidh Ainsworth, Hannah Walker for Phillips 66 mins

Scorers

Combined Provinces: Tries: Leah Tarpey 4 mins, Claire Bennett 18 mins, Maeve Og O’Leary 31 mins, Ella Roberts 38 mins, 65 mins mins, Aoife Dalton 51 mins, Deirbhile Nic a Bhaird 71 mins; Cons: Dannah O’Brien 4mins,18 mins, 31 mins, 51 mins, Hannah O’Connor 71 mins.

Scottish Thistles: Tries: Francesca McGhie 40 mins, 46 mins; Cons Emma Orr 46 mins.

Image credit: Inpho Photography

RELATED

Inter-District Squads confirmed for November campaign Cup & Competitions Inter-District Squads confirmed for November campaign Fri 30 Oct 2026 Hillhead Jordanhill and Watsonians set for top of the table clash Cup & Competitions Hillhead Jordanhill and Watsonians set for top of the table clash Thu 29 Oct 2026 GHA Come Out on Top in Stormy Glasgow Derby Cup & Competitions GHA Come Out on Top in Stormy Glasgow Derby Tue 27 Oct 2026 GHA prepare to welcome Glasgow Hawks for Glasgow derby Cup & Competitions GHA prepare to welcome Glasgow Hawks for Glasgow derby Fri 23 Oct 2026 Scotland Club XV Confirm Coaching Team for 2027 Cup & Competitions Scotland Club XV Confirm Coaching Team for 2027 Thu 22 Oct 2026 Melrose Rugby Claim Borders Derby Victory Over Hawick RFC Cup & Competitions Melrose Rugby Claim Borders Derby Victory Over Hawick RFC Tue 20 Oct 2026 Melrose Rugby Celebrate 150th Season Ahead of Borders Derby Cup & Competitions Melrose Rugby Celebrate 150th Season Ahead of Borders Derby Thu 15 Oct 2026 Watsonian FC Impress as the Arnold Clark Women’s Premiership Race Takes Shape Cup & Competitions Watsonian FC Impress as the Arnold Clark Women’s Premiership Race Takes Shape Tue 13 Oct 2026 Megan Gaffney Looks Back on Her Rugby Journey Ahead of Watsonian FC v Biggar RFC Cup & Competitions Megan Gaffney Looks Back on Her Rugby Journey Ahead of Watsonian FC v Biggar RFC Fri 9 Oct 2026 League Tables Taking Shape as Teams Battle for Position Cup & Competitions League Tables Taking Shape as Teams Battle for Position Tue 6 Oct 2026 Stuart Allison Ready to Lead Watsonian FC in Edinburgh Derby Cup & Competitions Stuart Allison Ready to Lead Watsonian FC in Edinburgh Derby Thu 1 Oct 2026 Historic Rivalry Leads Weekend of School and Club Rugby Cup & Competitions Historic Rivalry Leads Weekend of School and Club Rugby Tue 29 Sep 2026 Merchiston and Edinburgh Academy Renew Rugby’s Oldest School Rivalry Cup & Competitions Merchiston and Edinburgh Academy Renew Rugby’s Oldest School Rivalry Thu 24 Sep 2026 Competitions continue across the country Cup & Competitions Competitions continue across the country Tue 22 Sep 2026 Ollie Smith Looks Ahead to Scottish Rugby Match of the Week Between Marr Rugby and Ayr RFC Cup & Competitions Ollie Smith Looks Ahead to Scottish Rugby Match of the Week Between Marr Rugby and Ayr RFC Thu 17 Sep 2026 Competitions continue to gather pace as another weekend unfolds Cup & Competitions Competitions continue to gather pace as another weekend unfolds Tue 15 Sep 2026 Erskine Stewart Melville v Stirling County headlines this weekend’s action Cup & Competitions Erskine Stewart Melville v Stirling County headlines this weekend’s action Thu 10 Sep 2026 Currie hold off Heriot’s in Edinburgh Derby as busy club rugby weekend unfolds Cup & Competitions Currie hold off Heriot’s in Edinburgh Derby as busy club rugby weekend unfolds Tue 8 Sep 2026 Derby Day, Friday Night Lights and Premiership Action Await Cup & Competitions Derby Day, Friday Night Lights and Premiership Action Await Thu 3 Sep 2026 All eyes on the opening weekend of the Arnold Clark Women’s Premiership Cup & Competitions All eyes on the opening weekend of the Arnold Clark Women’s Premiership Tue 1 Sep 2026